7msports > Athletics Video > Pistorius prosecutor challenges physician's credibility

Pistorius prosecutor challenges physician's credibility

Tuesday, July 08 2014 by SNTV
  • Intro:

    On Monday, the chief prosecutor in the murder trial of Oscar Pistorius, Gerrie Nel, challenged the credibility of a physician, Wayne Derman, who testified that the athlete has an anxious nature linked to his disability.

    Script:

    SOUNDBITE: (English) Gerrie Nel, prosecutor

    "Remember we dealt with on Thursday with you being the treating physician and giving expert evidence on behalf on the accused. Can you remember that?

    SOUNDBITE: (English) WAYNE DERMAN, professor of sport

    "Yes my lady, I can. "

    SOUNDBITE: (English) Gerrie Nel, prosecutor.

    "You said that you don't think that there is conflict of interest to be able to do that."

    SOUNDBITE: (English) WAYNE DERMAN, professor of sport

    "My lady, I believe my report and my submission and my being here is as objective as I can be and I acknowledge I am his treating physician and wherever I can I have backed up my presentation with scientific evidence."

    SOUNDBITE: (English) Gerrie Nel, prosecutor

    " You are unable to be objective because you are a treating physician. So I am going to ask you a question based on that. If Mr Pistorius was a family member would you have had a problem in being objective expert?"

    SOUNDBITE: (English) WAYNE DERMAN, professor of sport

    "Yes sir, I would have."

    SOUNDBITE: (English) Gerrie Nel, prosecutor

    "Why would you draw a line between this person Mr Pistorius that you travelled the world with, spend lots of time with and a family member?"

    SOUNDBITE: (English) WAYNE DERMAN, professor of sport

    "My lady very simply because he is not a family member. He is one of a team of individuals that I travelled with. I believe that as a physician I Can be objective, I understand the issue that the prosecutor has and I believe I can be particularly with respect to my evidence that I have rendered in court."

Attention: Third parties may advertise their products and/or services on our website.7M does not warrant the accuracy, adequacy or completeness of their contents.
Your dealings with such third parties are solely between you and such third parties and we shall not be liable in any way for any loss or damage of any sort incurred by you.